Question

By cracking your fingers you start to develop Arthritis

Comments

It seems like the article linked claims that there is no scientific claim that cracking your knuckles will lead to a higher chance of developing arthritis or osteoarthritis.

---

This topic interests me because I crack my knuckles on a daily basis, and I have always wondered if this will cause my hands damage in the future. It seems like you got this information from a reputable source, BBC News, and that they stated many claims that were sourced very well. It is clear that they did thorough research on this topic and made sure their sources were correct. I am curious as to what the definitive conclusion of this article was though. It seems like there were some studies mentioned that showed affects of osteoarthritis from knuckle cracking, but there were also sources mentioned that the two have no correlation with each other. My suggestion would be to use another source that could defend one answer or the other with a more clear consensus on if cracking knuckles does cause osteoarthritis in the future.

---

This claim is not true. After browsing a few different websites, I have found that there is no actual scientific evidence to prove that cracking your knuckles causes arthritis. Reliable sources such as Harvard Health, John Hopkins Arthritis Center, and even Northwestern Medicine have confirmed this.

According to Harvard Health, this claim is just a myth. Studies have been conducted comparing hand rates of arthritis in those who cracked there knuckles have found that there is no correlation.

Though it should be noted that if one already has arthritis, cracking knuckles may worsen their symptoms. UAMS Health has confirmed that it is not the only reason for arthritis symptoms.

https://uamshealth.com/medical-myths/will-cracking-your-knuckles-cause-arthritis/

https://www.health.harvard.edu/pain/does-knuckle-cracking-cause-arthritis

https://www.nm.org/healthbeat/healthy-tips/can-you-get-arthritis-from-cracking-your-knuckles#:~:text=%E2%80%9CThe%20truth%20is%20there%20is,cracking%20your%20knuckles%20and%20arthritis.

---

This claim seems to be untrue. Northwestern Medicine's website says that "the popping noises when you crack your knuckles is caused by bursting gas bubbles in the fluid that helps lubricate your joints." The popping, is the bubbles when you pull or bend your fingers.(https://www.nm.org/healthbeat/healthy-tips/can-you-get-arthritis-from-cracking-yourknuckles#:~:text=%E2%80%9CThe%20truth%20is%20there%20is,cracking%20your%20knuckles%20and%20arthritis.) Also Harvard supports the claim that it doesn't cause arthritis as the bubbles bursting in the fluid helps lubricate the joints which doesn't cause long term damage.(https://www.health.harvard.edu/pain/does-knuckle-cracking-cause-arthritis)

---

You did a great job explaining that cracking your knuckles doesn't cause arthritis, using reliable sources like Harvard Health and Johns Hopkins to back up your points. While it’s true that there’s no evidence linking knuckle cracking to arthritis, it’s good to mention that it might cause other issues, such as joint swelling or reduced grip strength over time, according to UAMS Health. Adding an example like Dr. Donald Unger’s self-study, where he cracked one hand’s knuckles for years without any signs of arthritis, could make your argument even stronger. Overall, your response is solid, and including these details would improve it further!

---

Great job fact checking this! It's interesting how both Northwestern Medicine and Harvard emphasize that the sound from cracking knuckles is from gas bubbles, not joint damage, which debunks the arthritis myth. It’s reassuring to know that, according to these reliable sources, there’s no link between knuckle cracking and arthritis.

---

This is a great breakdown of the myth versus the facts. It’s really helpful that you highlighted sources like Harvard Health, Johns Hopkins, and Northwestern Medicine, because these organizations provide trustworthy, research-based information. The clarification about cracking knuckles possibly worsening symptoms for those with existing arthritis is also very informative. Your summary really clears up a common misconception.

---

In regards to the claim that cracking your knuckles will develop arthritis, the article does a good job providing evidence against this statement. Within the piece, the author includes a variety of sources that all suggest evidence that attribute to falsifying the initial claim. Although the author doesn't specify where the sources were gathered from, I was able to look each of them up and found multiple sites where this information was presented. Since the details of the information remained similar across the different sites, it is safe to say that it is reliable data from reliable sources. Additionally, BBC, where the article is posted, is known to be a trusted new broadcasting page. Overall, these factors can lead to the accountability of the article and justify the claim that cracking your knuckles will not cause arthritis problems in the future.

---

The article claims that people who crack their knuckles are more likely to get arthritis. It cites reputable sources, including the Family Board of Medicine and the National Library of Medicine. It outlines what cracking your knuckles is and how it works. The article addresses the lack of studies done on the subject. However, it uses the studies that have been done to show that, most likely, cracking your knuckles does not cause arthritis. The article starts with a question and successfully answers it. Overall, this is not clickbait and is true.

---

You effectively debunk the myth that cracking knuckles causes arthritis by citing reputable sources like Harvard Health, Johns Hopkins, and UAMS Health, all of which confirm no scientific evidence supporting this claim. You highlight studies showing no correlation between knuckle-cracking and arthritis, although it mentions that cracking may worsen symptoms in individuals who already have arthritis. However, the response could be improved with a more structured presentation, specific study details (e.g., Dr. Donald Unger’s experiment), and better integration of linked sources.

Answer 1

Cracking your knuckles does not directly lead to osteoarthrosis, known more commonly as arthritis. Tufts Medicine explains that this frequently heard rumor originated from adults who were attempting to discourage knuckle cracking because they had grown tired of hearing the excessive “popping” noise kids were constantly making. The National Library of Medicine references a study conducted where 300 patients, aged 45 years or above, who had no evidence of neuromuscular, inflammatory, or malignant disease were evaluated. The subjects did not have an increased development of arthritis. The John Hopkins Arthritis Center references this study when stating that cracking your knuckles does weaken your grip strength, as well as increase chance of ligament injuries or trauma to the joints. So, the “pop” that you hear is not your bones grinding together, but rather bubbles bursting in the synovial fluid, according to Harvard Health Publishing. Actually, a 1990 paper found that there is actually more swelling and inflammation in subjects who did not crack their knuckles, as reported by Tufts Medicine. This is also why you need to wait before cracking your knuckles again, as it takes twenty minutes for the bubbles to reform. Overall, cracking your knuckles may cause minor complications over time, but there is no evidence linking it to the development of arthritis.

Answer 2

The claim, "By cracking your fingers you start to develop arthritis", is false. Arthritis is pain that affects the ability to move a joint. People crack their knuckles to relieve joint tension, increase finger mobility, or just out of habit. There is no evidence that proves that cracking your knuckles causes arthritis. Osteoarthritis is a way more common, caused by overuse and wear and tear over time, which affects about 33 million U.S adults. 

Not only does cracking your knuckles not cause arthritis, it's actually completely harmless. A California physician conducted an experiment on himself where over his lifetime, he regularly cracked his knuckles but only on one hand. After decades of doing this, he checked x-rays and found no evidence of arthritis in his hands. 

https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/knuckle-cracking-annoying-and-harmful-or-just-annoying-2018051413797

Many people are told that if you crack your knuckles, you will get arthritis. Because of that, many people stop doing it as much, or stop completely. Though looking back at my information, it is clear that there is no evidence to this day that knuckle cracking causes arthritis, proving this claim false. 

https://www.hopkinsarthritis.org/arthritis-news/knuckle-cracking-q-a-from/

https://www.tridenthealthsystem.com/healthy-living/blog/does-cracking-knuckles-cause-arthritis