Question

Earth will get a second moon for two months

Comments

The main claim of this article is not completely untrue, although it is misleading. The asteroid 2024 PT5 was discovered by the Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System, and will orbit the Earth during September and November and appear as if Earth has a second moon. However, further research via the ATLAS and NASA websites does not indicate that the asteroid will be a moon or have the same properties as Earth’s moon.

---

This is a great detailed response.

---

This source is missing critical information like, the object's size, details about its composition, information about its origin, an explanation of how it was discovered and some mention of the uncertainty in the calculations.

---

This is a very vague response following a misleading argument. The article talks about an object that will orbit the country for a little while but is nothing close to a moon.

---

Your fact check on the asteroid 2024 PT5 is mostly accurate, but it could be clearer. You mentioned that the asteroid will appear as if Earth has a second moon, which is misleading. According to NASA and ATLAS, 2024 PT5 will not be captured by Earth’s gravity and will remain about nine times farther away from Earth than the Moon. This means it won’t have the same properties or appearance as Earth’s moon. It would be helpful to clarify this distinction to avoid misconceptions. Additionally, while you did a good job referencing ATLAS and NASA, it would strengthen your argument to include specific data or quotes from these sources. For example, NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory provides detailed information about the asteroid’s orbit around the Sun, which supports your point that it won’t orbit Earth. Including this information would make your fact check more robust and informative. Overall, your fact check is well-researched, but adding these details would improve its clarity and accuracy.

Answer 1

While the claim that the earth will be getting a second moon for 2 months, is true, it lacks context. The second moon, a school bus sized asteroid known as 2024 PT5, began orbiting the earth on September 29th. The way the claim is phrased is sensationalized in order to drive click. The earth fairly regularly picks up stray astroids and comets and pulls them into an orbit for a few weeks or months before they drift back out into a solar orbit. 

Source: https://www.nbcmiami.com/weather/stories-weather/earth-just-got-a-second-moon-but-not-for-long-heres-why/3433266/#:~:text=A%20second%20moon%20joined%20the,and%20will%20briefly%20orbit%20earth.

Answer 2

This claim is exaggerated and misleading. The article states that the second moon will be a small asteroid orbiting the planet. This is misleading because asteroids are much different than moons. Yes, a small asteroid will gravitate around the planet, but it is by no means a second moon. While the information about the asteroid and its path in space is correct, the idea that it is a second moon is false and misleading.

Answer 3

I believe the claim is somewhat accurate but needs further clarification. The news article by CBS, states that an asteroid named 2024 PT5 is predicted to orbit Earth more temporarily as a "mini-moon", from late Sept. to late Nov. With that being said, fully claiming a second moon can make the reader think that a whole new planet is set to be created. The mini-moon isn't a permanent second moon, as it will eventually resume orbiting the Sun and be away from Earth. 2024 PT5 is larger than some previous mini-moons, but its small size and temporary orbit distinguish it from Earth’s permanent moon.

source: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/earth-second-mini-moon-2024/

Answer 4

Earth will not get a second moon; instead, its gravitational pull will capture an asteroid named 2024 PT5. The asteroid will stay in orbit for around two months. This claim is not entirely false, as Earth will be getting a new object in its gravitational pull, but it is merely an asteroid, not a moon.

Answer 5

The claim that Earth will get a "second moon" is pretty misleading, it is not a moon in the same sense as Earth's moon we all know, but rather an asteroid that finds its way into Earth's orbit temporarily. The phenomena is relatively common, the "mini moon" does not affect Earth in the same way the moon does, and will leave Earth's orbit after a couple years. To call it a "second moon" is an exaggerated claim.

https://www.space.com/earth-will-capture-second-moon-sept-2024

Answer 6

The fact-check seems a little deceptive. A "second moon" isn't really mentioned in the essay. It might be more precise to refer to the smaller asteroid that will orbit Earth as a "tiny asteroid near the moon" compared to as a "little moon."

Answer 7

The true claim of the CBS article is misleading. While the information is true on the surface, the nature of what is actually rotating around the Earth is very different than “another moon”. Reading enough into the article, you can find the claim that the Earth will have a second moon when a small asteroid begins to orbit our planet” (CBS). NASA writes that this asteroid will NOT be orbiting around Earth’s gravity rather than just a notable floating object. Also, the moon is a completely different type of object than an asteroid. Moons have phases and changes that do not exist within the makeup of an asteroid. While it is a notable object, the title is misleading in what the object is, and how it ended up in our orbit. A more accurate title may be that the Earth has a “moon like object” for the next 2 months to clarify it is not inherently a moon. 

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/earth-second-mini-moon-2024/ 

https://science.nasa.gov/planetary-defense/ 

Answer 8

The argument that "Earth will get a second moon for two months" is fundamentally true, but the second moon isn't what most people would picture. Rather than a natural satellite, the Earth will gain a tiny, captured asteroid named 2024 PT5—an object that's about the size of a car and which its discoverers have classified as a "mini-moon." Starting on September 29, 2024, this capture will happen and will last until about November 25, 2024, when 2024 PT5 will escape back into the solar system.

Comments

source: https://www.kxan.com/news/earths-2nd-moon-has-arrived-what-you-need-to-know/#:~:text=(KTLA)%20%E2%80%93%20A%20second%20moon,an%20asteroid%20named%202024%20PT5.

Answer 9

In the article provided by CBS, a reliable national news channel, their attention-grabbing headline exaggerates the truth a bit. Earth will experience an asteroid, that is a bit taller than a giraffe (so too small to see without any professional equipment), come into orbit for about two months and leave promptly. This asteroid is only referenced as a 'moon' since it orbits the Earth in a horseshoe motion for a bit, but this is only used as exaggeration or for comedic purposes. According to https://phys.org/news/2024-09-earth-capture-moon-weekend-nasa.html#google_vignette, the mini moon is "apart of the Arjuna asteroid belt, a secondary asteroid belt made of space rocks that follow orbits similar to that of Earth at an average distance to the sun of about 93 million miles."