Ketchup is unhealthy for us as humans

Question

Ketchup has a lot of salt in it. Too much salt can be unhealthy for pretty much anyone. I read an article on healthline.com. It read, "Most packaged ketchup products are also high in salt. If you're sensitive to salt, eating too much salt may contribute to high blood pressure, heart disease, and other health concerns." Because of that, Ketchup can be unhealthy for us. 

Comments

I think that this post is completely misleading but also false. The article talked about how healthy tomatoes are and the benefits one can have by consuming them. They did talk about how consuming five tablespoons could be harmful if you are sensitive to salt."Eating ketchup in moderation, such as a few tablespoons at a time, doesn’t carry many risks." (healthline.com)

---

I feel like your answer could include some stats. Like how much salt is actually in one packet of ketchup, and how much salt on average one person should consume. I think it would also be good to include what the source you provided says about healthy tomatoes, and their benefits. But otherwise you did a good job covering the high blood pressure, heart disease, and other health concerns.

Answer 1

This claim is false. While the information stated is true, it is very exaggerated. As said above, ketchup is high in salt but that does not make it unhealthy. Healthline.com points out both the health benefits and side effects ketchup has. Some benefits includes it acts like an antioxidant, supports your brain, and promotes heart health. The article also mentions some side effects which includes its high in salt and sugar, and some may be allergic. While ketchup is not bad for humans, it is typically eaten in small portions which is what makes it good for you. If you start eating ketchup in larger portions, that is when it may start to get unhealthy.

https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/ketchup-nutrition-facts#side-effects

Comments

I appreciate how you outlined the key points in a concise way and explained how ketchup is only unhealthy if eaten excessively. I wonder if you were able to find other articles that support the claim that ketchup is not bad for your health?

---

I liked that you brought up other sections of the article that were not acknowledged in the claim like the benefits ketchup can have. I also liked that you talked about portion sizes and that aside from people with allergies and other existing medical conditions, most people are eating small enough amounts of ketchup that it wouldn't have much of an impact.

---

I like how you explained your fact-check by saying that the information was very exaggerated, which is a key component to look out for in fact-checking different theories and opinions. I also liked how you used your source to help you gain knowledge about the ingredients used in ketchup and the effect it has on health.

Answer 2

I find this claim to be false. The article linked explains the ingredients and nutrition facts found in most ketchup brands. It also includes the numerous health benefits that come from ketchup's main ingredient, tomatoes. The author touches on the high levels of sugar and salt but mentions that eating an excessive amount (4-5+ tablespoons) of ketchup per meal could cause mild side effects of high blood pressure or heart disease if previously sensitive to salt. Like all processed foods with high salt and sugar counts, it's not necessarily the best source of nutrition for humans (Harvard.edu), but for ketchup, "Eating ketchup in moderation — such as a few tablespoons at a time — doesn’t carry many risks." (healthline.com) 

Comments

I appreciate how you pointed out that the claim is ignoring significant parts of the article like the section where it lists the health benefits of ketchup. I think the key word that is important to this situation was moderation, which was supplied by a quote from Harvard, a relatively reliable source. I also appreciate how you pointed out the limitations of both sides of the argument, yes ketchup can be bad for you but there are aspects of it that are good for you.

---

I think you did a good job fact checking a pointing out how over consuming anything can be bad for someone. You could have furthered your fact checking by digging a little deeper into the sources the claim came from- was it reliable? Was there dietitians/doctors involved in the research behind any claims made? Additionally, does it matter which ketchup is consumed? Or are all ketchups equally "bad" for people. There are various ways to expand on your previous research.

Answer 3

This claim is false. This article has a whole section dedicated to the health benefits of ketchup. In the article it states, "If you enjoy ketchup, you may be happy to hear that because it’s made with tomatoes, it’s a good source of lycopene. Adding more lycopene to your diet may help protect you from cancer, heart disease, and other chronic conditions." The only thing that makes ketchup unhealthy is if you have it in very large quantities. Yes, if you're sensitive to salt you shouldn't eat it because of the salt but most people are not and can enjoy ketchup if they'd like to, so saying that it is "unhealthy for us as humans" is just not true. I found other articles about this topic saying the same thing, that it can be healthy for you as long as you don't eat way too much. According to verywellfit.com, "Ketchup may be a source of added calories, sugar and sodium, but because it is usually not consumed in large quantities, it can be included in a healthy diet."

https://www.verywellfit.com/ketchup-nutrition-facts-and-health-benefits-5024895

Comments

This is a very good fact check. It looks like you read the source they included in the claim to prove that this claim is false. I also like how you included your own source to back up why you think ketchup can be good for people in moderation. Next time, I would include less quotes from the article. This sometimes makes it hard for the reader to understand and comprehend what they are reading.

---

This fact check does a very good job of providing information on why the fact check is false. I like how you proved that the fact check was false by providing some examples from the original article. You also did a good job of providing an example from a different article that backs up the fact that ketchup can still be included in a healthy diet. You also did a good job of acknowledging  the fact that ketchup can be negative to ones health in some cases.