1 like 0 dislike
in General Factchecking by Novice (940 points)
An avian flu pandemic could be imminent.

1 Answer

0 like 0 dislike
by Newbie (400 points)

Although the New York Times is undoubtedly a reliable news source, it is important to note that this is an opinion piece, and therefore cannot be compared to the same standards of truth as a traditional news claim. We can however, analyze the sources and evidence present in the text to determine where they fall on the scale of misinformation. Author Zeynep Tufecki, a NYT columnist and Princeton professor of sociology, focuses her argument on the H5N1 Avian Flu, a virus that while extremely rare in humans, is spreading in animals. She also cites Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who is Donald Trump's selection to lead the Public Health Agency, as saying he "would not prioritize research or vaccine distribution were we to face another pandemic," a correct paraphrasing of Kennedy's views on vaccines as discussed in this interview with NBC News. Tufecki links to several other articles about avian flu, from the NYT and other sources, which provide alternate perspectives to her claim. So while the nature of an opinion piece prohibits it from being labeled as misinformation or not misinformation, Tufecki's argument is sourced by evidence which is verifiable and true.

Can't be true or false (Opinion, poem, etc.)
by Apprentice (1.7k points)
0 0
This is a very well-rounded factcheck! You have very strong sources and are able to hold your sources/claim up well.
by Newbie (350 points)
0 0
I appreciate how thoughtfully you answered this question. You really went above and beyond just noting that this is an opinion piece. The way that you reason whether or not the content of the opinion piece can be backed up with data/evidence creates a cohesive and complete analysis of the argument. Well done!

Community Rules


• Be respectful
• Always list your sources and include links so readers can check them for themselves.
• Use primary sources when you can, and only go to credible secondary sources if necessary.
• Try to rely on more than one source, especially for big claims.
• Point out if sources you quote have interests that could affect how accurate their evidence is.
• Watch for bias in sources and let readers know if you find anything that might influence their perspective.
• Show all the important evidence, whether it supports or goes against the claim.
...