Excessive makeup is damaging to skin

Question

Even though applying makeup is fun and can improve confidence, using too much all at once can have negative impact to skin, such as clogging pores, causing breakouts, and irritating skin. It is better to limit the use of makeup to minimize effects it might cause in the future.

Answer 1

The claim, "excessive makeup is damaging to skin" is a broad statement. While looking at the article provided, I didn't find a claim with evidence, or any claim for that matter, stating that an excessive amount of makeup is damaging to skin. I was able to find similar statements, such as makeup will clog your pores if worn for long periods of time, and could cause wrinkles. I also found that makeup can trigger already existing breakouts, or begin the start of a new breakout if worn to often/ too long. However, there wasn't a single statement in the article that supported the claim of excessive makeup being damaging to skin. It moreso focuses on the fact that there's a good chance of a breakout/ wrinkle damage if left on the face for a long period of time. 

I researching more in an attempt to find different (or similar) evidence regarding the damage that excessive makeup causes. According to dermatologists at DCSI, makeup can cause damage but only through lack of proper cleansing, application of products that aren't safe/ healthy, and by using oil based products. However, the article doesn't provide any claim agreeing with the fact that excessive makeup can by harmful. As long as you're staying consistent with hygene and making sure your products are skin friendly, then there shouldn't be an issue regarding how much you have on your face. 

https://www.kalosmedicalspa.com/how-makeup-affects-skin-health/#:~:text=When%20worn%20for%20long%20periods,90%25%20of%20visible%20skin%20aging.

https://www.mydcsi.com/2023/09/28/does-wearing-makeup-age-your-skin/

Answer 2

The main claim is that using too much makeup at once can clog pores, cause breakouts and irritation. No evidence is provided besides the article. After reading the article, no concrete evidence is provided, rather claims are made. These claims range from negative affects of makeup and some solutions are provided as well to prevent these affects. There aren't any studies cited to back these claims. The website is the website for Kalos, which is a medical spa in Fort Worth, Texas located in a plastic surgery office called Kirby Plastic Surgery. There are some credentials provided at the end of the article, Dr. Emily J. Kirby who is the lead plastic surgeon of Kalos Medical Spa and Kirby Plastic Surgery. This adds some validity to the article but for the most part this seems like an advertisement for the Kalos and Kirby. When I looked for a study to potentially back these claims or a valid website I couldn't find any and rather just more websites for spas like Kalos. Based on my own reading of the article, the negative effects they say makeup can have on your skin seem reasonable and aren't outlandish at all but again there isn't any evidence or studies to back these claims. I would say that these claims aren't not true but most likely exaggerated to make Kalos' claim stronger for why you should visit their spa.

Comments

You did well with proving why the original claim may be misleading. You explained thoroughly with your research on why the original claim may be misleading. Although you should also include another source to back your claim.

---

I think you did a great job analyzing the claim by pointing out the article from the original claim is from a medical spa, and thus it's entirely likely they're trying to draw in consumers. One area I believe you could improve in would be to find a reliable and unbiased source that validates and proves your answer. Your current response is strong and very thorough and insightful, but if you were to include another source to back it up, it would make it that much better. All in all excellent job!

---

I appreciate how you broke down the parts of the article and questioned its overall validity. This opened my eyes to a new perspective of viewing this source, especially how it’s mildly promotional.

Answer 3

The article discusses several potential negative impacts of makeup on the skin, as it mentions that it can clog pores, lead to breakouts, and irritate the skin. Though these things are true, the article also mentions how choosing the right makeup products that go well with your kin can reduce health risks and prevent damage to the skin. For instance, choosing products that are suitable for your skin type or include healthy ingredients, removing makeup thoroughly at the end of the day and not sleeping with it on, and using safe and trusted skincare brands can all reduce the harmful effects that makeup can potentially have on the skin. Therefore, the phrase "excessive makeup" can be somewhat misleading, as the real issue lies in the combination of how and how often makeup is applied, as well as the types of products used and the suitability of the makeup to your face. Furthermore, the article linked below shares insights from a dermatologist, stating how taking a break from wearing makeup can help the skin repair itself.

https://www.nbcnews.com/better/lifestyle/i-went-makeup-free-2-weeks-here-s-what-happened-ncna1103521

Comments

You accurately show that the original claim is exaggerated. I like how you break-down the specific terminology that causes it to be misleading. I also appreciate that you added a source of your own to back up the argument.

Answer 4

The article primarily argues that excessive makeup use can clog pores, trigger breakouts, and cause irritation. However, it provides no evidence to support these claims, aside from the article itself. Upon reading it, I found that the article makes broad assertions without offering concrete proof. It outlines the potential negative effects of makeup on the skin, along with some tips to avoid these issues, but there are no referenced studies to back up these statements. The article appears on the Kalos website, a medical spa located in Fort Worth, Texas, within the Kirby Plastic Surgery office. While the article includes credentials, such as mentioning Dr. Emily J. Kirby, the lead plastic surgeon at Kalos Medical Spa and Kirby Plastic Surgery, this lends some authority but still seems largely promotional. When I searched for scientific studies or credible sources to back the article’s claims, I only found more spa-related websites like Kalos. From my reading, the negative effects of makeup seem plausible, but without evidence or studies to support the claims, it’s likely that they are exaggerated to promote the spa's services.

Comments

You're totally right to be skeptical about the claims in that article. While it does mention that makeup could cause skin issues like clogged pores or breakouts, it doesn't back those up with solid scientific studies—just general advice. Plus, since it's from a medical spa, there's definitely a promotional angle, which can make things seem exaggerated. It would be good to check out more reliable sources, like dermatology studies, for a more balanced view on the effects of makeup.

Answer 5

The claim that "excessive makeup is damaging to the skin" turn outs to be a false statement. In the article referenced there is only statement and there is no study to back up any of the claims bur as said, only statements. When you get to the premature aging section of the article it claims, "when worn for long periods of time, makeup clogs your pores and therefore limits collagen and elastin production on your skin." With such aa statement as is there is no evidence nor credibility to support the claims. 

However, there are many articles that ask skin care professionals that say otherwise about makeup being harmful for the skin. The article "OK, Exactly How Bad Actually is Makeup for Your Skin?" written by Emma Hobday, goes into detail when asking Advanced Aesthetic Docter Dr. Sebastian Bejma and biochemist aesthetician Valerie Aparovich.The both of them seem to say that then main issue with this misconception is that "inadequate skincare prep, inadequate makeup removal, and using makeup products that are unsuitable for your skintype," are the most probable reasons as to why people struggle with it/ Aparovich continues to say "if you're applying and removing makeup correctly, then wearing makeup daily can't be treating your skin badly." Dr. Bejima goes into detail about what could be beneficial to take care of your skin, alongside the heavy recommendation of someone to wear sunscreen in order to hydrate your skin most effectively before applying makeup.

The article "Think Makeup Is Bad For Your Skin? We Asked Skin Professionals to Find Out," written by Verily Magazine, gives us more insight when it comes to the alleged negatives of wearing makeup. The article mentions three people they ask to see if there's any negatives to wearing makeup; the three come to the conclusion that it depends on your skin type, the type of product, and if the product is damaging, to try a new brand. Ariel Enriquez who is a Skin Trainer at Massage Retreat & Spa, says that it's important for his clients to double cleanse your skin when you're wearing makeup, and to never sleep in makeup. Dr Joel Schlessinger, who is a board certified dermatologist, completely agrees with the statement Enriquez made, saying it "can cause clogged pores, breakouts, irritation and rough skin texture... and bacterial buildup." 

Both of the articles contain different people who are certified to be in the skincare field, and all of their statements come to the same agreements, its only unhealthy if it bothers your skin type and proper removal so your pores don't get clogged up; with the addition of proper skin hydration by wearing SPF sunscreen.

Source: Wait, is Makeup Actually Bad for Your Skin?

Source: Think Makeup Is Bad for Your Skin? We Asked Skin Professionals to Find Out - Verily

Answer 6

The main claim here is that using too much makeup can damage your skin. Although all skin is different, this is altogether true. According to Dr. Cameron Rokhsar, wearing makeup for long periods of time may have a negative effect on the health of your skin." It's important to note the article included to back up this initial claim is written by a medical spa, which profits off of women's insecurities and the claim that makeup damages skin.

Comments

Make sure to include the source of the information from which the doctor is mentioning this claim.