Native Americans are More Likely to be Affected by Alcoholism Compared to Other Groups.

Question

This claim is true however it is not for the reasons many people may think and is not true for all Natives. There is no evidence that there are genetic factors increasing the rate at which Indigenous communities are affected by alcoholism. Abusable forms of alcohol were largely introduced to tribes by European colonizers. With the presence of these colonizers also came traumatic events such as forced assimilation, slavery, and physical abuse that all could lead to mental health conditions that have direct correlations with alcoholism.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/omerawan/2023/11/15/alcohol-and-its-effect-on-the-health-of-native-americans/

https://www.samhsa.gov/data/sites/default/files/TEDS-Spot146-AIAN-2014/TEDS-Spot146-AIAN-2014.htm

Answer 1

An article from the National Library of Medicine came up to a similar conclusion saying, "The high rates of substance dependence seen in some tribes is likely a combination of a lack of genetic protective factors combined with genetically mediated risk factors that combine with key environmental factors to produce increased risk for the disorder." After running studies on heritability, linkage analyses, and candidate genes, they were able to come to the same conclusion how Native Americans are more likely to be affected by alcoholism.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3603686/

Comments

Finn, I appreciate that you brought in genetic research as the National Library of Medicine source adds a layer of complexity that’s often missing from oversimplified takes. That said, I think it’s really important to highlight that the presence of “genetically mediated risk factors” doesn’t mean there’s a unique biological flaw in Native communities. The same study you cited also emphasizes that environmental factors such as historical trauma, systemic oppression, and poverty are just as important in shaping outcomes. Framing it as a "lack of protective factors" could reinforce harmful stereotypes if not contextualized carefully. Maybe clarifying that these genetic influences exist across all populations, but interact with social conditions differently, would make your answer more responsible and clear.

---

I like the research you provided and the reputable science resources, it helps put not only genetic risk factors into the scope of everything but it helps portray the socioeconomic factors that can and have contributed to it over the years. The depth you went to to not only research and confirm the claim but further provide context was phenomenal.

Answer 2

An article from the National Library of Medicine states that there is a substantial genetic component in Native Americans as well as other populations. Some groups of people have mutated enzymes that affect the metabolization of alcohol. Although most groups have the protective enzyme Native Americans lack variants seen in other populations.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3603686/

Comments

This is a fantastic answer, that gets into the specifics of things without getting overly long. I do wish it addressed a few of the other claims as well- such as the rate Native Americans are actually alcoholic in comparison to non-natives.

---

This is a good reply, but it would be nice to see the validity of the source and have that proven in your statement. Also, the original statement linked three sources while you only linked one of them. This calls in to question the validity of these sources, which were used to fully craft this idea about Native Americans being connected with alcoholism.

---

I think that is very interesting how a certain type of person is more prone to alcohol, more than another person, solely off their ethnicity. Is it have to do strictly with their enzymes?

---

This is particularly interesting, as many aspects have been under-researched, and the way bodies metabolize alcohol is undoubtedly one of them, which is why I enjoyed the portion of your answer where you touched on the enzymes involved in the metabolism process.

Answer 3

Though it is absolutely true that trauma can increase vulnerability to alcoholism [1], the sources you use to corroborate your claim that Natives are both more likely to suffer from alcoholism and aren't genetically vulnerable to the addiction are both either less credible or older than sources I could find claiming the opposite. The national library of medicine has an article analyzing the number of natives who have a genetic risk of alcoholism. It is increased compared to the non-native population, though it is worth noting that non-native people are also at risk of genetic predisposition to alcoholism as well.[2] An article in the Drug and Alcohol Dependence journal as hosted on ScienceDirect has a study into alcohol use among natives and found that they were more likely to abstain than non-native counterparts.[3]

SOURCES
[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6561398/
[2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3603686/
[3] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S037687161501830X

Answer 4

I appreciate your claim and that you point out that the general statement can be misleading. While there has been a documented higher rate of alcohol abuse among native americans, there are numerous factors that play a role in that, including treatment by the American government.

https://americanaddictioncenters.org/rehab-guide/addiction-statistics-demographics/native-americans

Comments

I agree with your statement! I think the claim starts with a stereotype and can cause misleading or biased information towards those reading the claims. Providing data for not only Native Americans, but also other factors that may contribute, is super helpful to bust the claim.

---

I appreciate you bringing nuance into your response — acknowledging the data while also highlighting the deeper historical and social context. Your point about the role of the U.S. government is really important and often overlooked in surface-level discussions. I would suggest a direct quote from your article to better reinforce and justify your factcheck

---

I also agree with your response! The original claim seems rooted in a stereotype like another comment mentioned. This lead to a misleading interpretations at first glance. The way you included data on Native Americans along with other factors really helps break down the claim and provide a more accurate picture.

---

I agree with your response. I like how you mentioned that there are numerous factors that play a role in this claim of Native Americans having a higher chance of struggling from alcoholism. I would've liked to see maybe another source that documents one of these other factors that aren't frequently mentioned. One could be how alcohol was introduced to Native Americans in the first place. From what I gather, Alcohol came to Native Americans through trade with European colonists.