0 like 0 dislike
ago in General Factchecking by Newbie (310 points)

A meme posted on Facebook by the group “Patriot Energy Facts. I’ve heard this claim repeated in energy debates, especially by those opposing wind power, but I’ve also seen environmentalists strongly dispute it. I want to fact-check it to see what the actual data says.

2 Answers

0 like 0 dislike
ago by Novice (520 points)
selected ago by
 
Best answer

An estimated 500,000 birds die worldwide due to oil spill every year. This is especially important because seabirds are the most commonly endangered type of bird (https://ornithology.com/birds-and-oil-spills/). During just a single oil spill incident, Deepwater Horizon, 800,000 coastal birds and 200,000 offshore birds died (https://www.audubon.org/news/more-one-million-birds-died-during-deepwater-horizon-disaster). In addition to this, oil spills kill and endanger many other animals, such as fur bearing animals like sea otters, to sea turtles, dolphins, whales, fish, shellfish, and coral (https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/oilimpacts.html)

Although wind turbines do kill a significant number of birds every year (somewhere between 140,000 and 680,000), they are significantly less damaging than oil spills (https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/do-wind-turbines-kill-birds). These numbers are statistically smaller than deaths by oil spill, but they are also less horriffic, as it is only a fraction as many birds are killed per year by housecats, cars, buildings, or the  lethal fossil fuel operations being replaced by turbines.  Wind projects kill 0.269 birds per gigawatt hour of electricity produced, compated to 5.18 birds per the same unit by fossil fuel projects (https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/do-wind-turbines-kill-birds-and-other-climate-questions/). So Ultimately, no, wind turbines do not kill more birds than oil spills, which have many more terrible repercussions, and wind turbines are better for birds than other alternatives. 

False
0 like 0 dislike
ago by Newbie (300 points)

 

The claims that “wind turbines kill more birds than oil spills” is not true. While wind turbines do kill some birds, the number is much lower than the deaths caused by the oil industry. Experts estimate that wind turbines in the U.S. kill between 140,000 and 500,000 birds each year. Some studies say the number might rise as more turbines are built, but it's still far less than often claimed. I do like the meme reference though!

False
ago by Innovator (61.1k points)
0 0
What's your source? I don't see any mentioned, but you stated "experts". Who are you referring to?
ago by Novice (600 points)
0 0
This is in fact true but, if you are tryin g to make the claim that wind turbines are as bad as oil spills that would be false. Wind turbines provide clean energy while oil spills harm are entire planet not just birds.

Community Rules


• Be respectful
• Always list your sources and include links so readers can check them for themselves.
• Use primary sources when you can, and only go to credible secondary sources if necessary.
• Try to rely on more than one source, especially for big claims.
• Point out if sources you quote have interests that could affect how accurate their evidence is.
• Watch for bias in sources and let readers know if you find anything that might influence their perspective.
• Show all the important evidence, whether it supports or goes against the claim.
...