Question

Dogs can only see black and white

Comments

It seems that the claim was untrue and misleading. It was proven wrong by many sources before, and it originated from an author of DogWeek Magazine. Great fact check!

---

This claim is seemingly incorrect, as there’s no source to back up the claim.

---

I really like how this explains the myth in a simple, easy to understand way! The comparison to red/green color blindness makes it super clear, and the AKC citation is a nice touch it makes the info feel really credible. Great job!

---

The claim that dogs can only see black and white is false. Dogs can see shades of blue and yellow, but have difficulty distinguishing between red and green.

---

The claim that "Dogs can only see black and white" has long been a popular and widley shared belief. However, recent scientific research has proved that this myth is incorrect. Supporting the idea that dogs do see color, however, not in the way that humans do. I discovered that dogs have only 20% of the cells that humans have, which are for detecting color. (Pedigree, 2025). Because of the lack of cells that dogs have, their vision is more limited, only seeing yellow and blue shades. Many media sources altered the assumption that dogs only see in black and white, without prven evidence.However, research specifically in veterinary studies has provided evidence that while dogs do not see the full spectrum of colors like humans, they are not colorblind in the way previously thought, only susceptible to certain shades.
Sources: https://www.pedigree.com/dog-care-articles/our-help-hub/training-resources/do-dogs-see-only-in-black-and-white

Answer 1

This claim is false. 

The American Kennel Club (AKC) explains the origin of this false understanding. The AKC states, "The notion that dogs see only in shades of black and white has been attributed to Will Judy, a lifelong dog fancier, writer, and past publisher of Dog Week magazine...'It’s likely that all the external world appears to them as varying highlights of black and gray,' Judy wrote in his 1937 manual, “Training the Dog.”" 

Dogs do have more limited color vision than humans. The site Dogs Naturally has an article explaining this. It states, "Your dog’s eyes...only have two cones – blue and yellow. This is called dichromatic vision, and it means that while your dog can still see color, his perception of it is muted compared to a human. The biggest difference is that dogs can’t process red light, which can make it hard for them to distinguish certain colors." These certain colors dogs are unable to process are red and green, and colors involving them. 

For more information and visuals on the differences in color perception between humans and dogs, check out this webpage: https://dog-vision.andraspeter.com/#Color

https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/health/can-dogs-see-color/

https://www.dogsnaturallymagazine.com/what-colors-do-dogs-see/

Comments

This is a great claim. I love how you included trustworthy sources, used real quotes and evidence, and explained your evidence. Providing multiple creditable links to the sources used shows that your fact check is trustworthy. This made it very easy to understand and clearly shows that the original claim was false.

---

The evidence you used was great and support your claim. I also really liked how you explain where the common misconception comes from.

---

I like how you explained your claim, but I was a little unsure about one of your sources. Where did that information originally come from? It kind of seems like it might just be repeating something from another site without explaining the actual evidence behind it. Maybe try tracing it back to a study or expert so it feels more reliable. Your explanation makes sense, I just think adding that extra step would make it stronger.

---

Great job! I like that you showed a source showing where the myth came from. Your explanation is really clear and the sources and quotes make your argument really solid.

---

I fact-checked the claim that dogs can only see in black and white, and it turns out that’s actually a myth. According to the American Kennel Club (AKC), dogs are actually "dichromatic," which means they have two types of color-detecting cells in their eyes instead of the three that humans have. I traced this back to research from the Neitz Lab at the University of Washington, where scientists found that dogs see the world mostly in shades of blue and yellow. They can’t really see red or green (to them, a red ball in green grass just looks like different shades of brownish-gray), but they definitely aren't living in a black-and-white movie. This "monochrome" idea mostly started because of outdated assumptions from the 1930s before we had the technology to actually test canine vision properly.

Answer 2

It is a common misconception that dogs can only see in black and white. The way color is perceived is derived from the number of cones and rods in the eye. The difference between the human and dog eye is that "dogs have have more rods than cones in their retina, whereas people have more cones" (Meyers). Dogs have dichromatic vision. Because of this, dogs are capable of also seeing yellow and blue colors, yet they cannot see red an green. Thus, dogs can see more colors than black and white (greyish tones).

https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/health/can-dogs-see-color/

Comments

It's fascinating that dogs have dichromatic vision, allowing them to see yellow and blue but not red or green, disproving the black-and-white vision myth.

---

I appreciate that your fact check supports your claim with specific evidence to prove that this claim is false. This fact check is very good but I think incorporating another source would make this an even stronger argument.

---

I think you did a great job pointing out why the poster may have had this belief, but then go into why the claim is false. Incorporating the anatomy of a dogs eye makes your fact check even more reliable. Although I think if you used more sources and possibly even a credible source it would help strengthen your argument.

---

Great claim and the evidence used directly shows how the claim is false and its easy to find. You went on both sides and saw their thinking when making this claim and then you went on to disprove it. Great job.

---

You right  dogs does not see just black and white, and white.They can see some colors,Mainly blue and yellow, but red and green look more brown to them so i think their colour world is not a ours, it is not just shades of gray.

Answer 3

According to the link below, cats and dogs have two types of cones that respond to blue and green light. This suggests they have adequate color vision.

https://adelaidevet.com.au/pet-library/can-animals-see-colour#:~:text=It%20was%20once%20thought%20that,the%20eye%20called%20cone%20photoreceptors.

Comments

This is a decent article, it provides a great explanation to back up your answer. However, there's no clear author or apparent publish date on the article, which means this information could potentially be quite outdated and inaccurate. I'd suggest looking for articles within a couple years and that have an author who you can look up and verify their credibility. Information like that goes a long way in backing up your claims and makes it that much more valuable.

---

Well put, but the article provided Cites "scientists" as the source of this being a myth. I don't think this is very convincing source, something more convincing would be an article that provides a source, or even better the actual original research paper.

---

I appreciate the link to the article speaking more on this topic. Although, it would have been helpful to see more information in your post on this topic before I delved into the article.

---

Although I agree with your fact check and I appreciate the article attached, I think your claim would benefit from another stronger source. The article you linked does back up your claim, but it isn't extensive and doesn't provide any evidence, so I would suggest finding a second source that does. You could also explain why dogs see the way they do instead of only stating that they do have some color vision.

---

I agree with you but the article you provided isn't enough evidence. There are holes in it including lack of evidence and time stamp. May I suggest finding more than one article next time to double check your facts?

---

I think you did a really good job breaking this down in a way that’s easy to understand. One thing you could maybe add is a bit more about where the information originally came from, like who conducted the research or why they’re a trusted source. That would make your argument feel even more solid. But overall your reasoning was clear and I liked how you explained it.

Answer 4

In the past people believed that dogs could see in black and white but that has been proven to be a myth. In fact according to Adelaine Vet, dogs and cats are colourblind " humans use three cones – red, blue and green. However cats and dogs only have blue and green cones. This means they have a much more muted perception of colour, which is akin to colour blindness in humans". Some way or form dogs can't see in full color. 

https://adelaidevet.com.au/pet-library/can-animals-see-colour#:~:text=It%20was%20once%20thought%20that%20animals%2C%20including%20cats,of%20cells%20in%20the%20eye%20called%20cone%20photoreceptors.

Comments

I agree with your claim, but I don't think your source provides enough information to prove it to be true or false. It just describes that dogs have different rods and cons than humans, but not why this is the case.

Answer 5

it is wrong dogs can see colors, according to AdelaideVet:

"It was once thought that animals, including cats and dogs, could only see in black and white. However, scientists have proven this to be a myth"

https://adelaidevet.com.au/pet-library/can-animals-see-colour#:~:text=It%20was%20once%20thought%20that,the%20eye%20called%20cone%20photoreceptors.

Comments

I like that your source is from a veterinarian site but I think it would be more reliable if the statements had sources that supported the statements they put in response to the myths.

Answer 6

While scientists previously believed that animals were only able to see in black in white this has been proven wrong recently, making this statement false. Dogs cannot see color as much as humans as humans use three cones and dogs use two, however they still have a perception of color.

https://adelaidevet.com.au/pet-library/can-animals-see-colour#:~:text=Animals%20only%20see%20in%20black%20and%20white&text=It%20was%20once%20thought%20that,the%20eye%20called%20cone%20photoreceptors.

Comments

Hello, your fact check was very detailed and helpful for our understanding. to add, from my research I found the specific cones dog have in their eyes. Dogs have 2 cones in their eyes that allow them to see blue and yellow while being blind to red and green.

Answer 7

<!--StartFragment-->

New research and conclusions about dogs show that while dogs may not be able to see as much as humans do, dogs can still see a mass proportion of colors as we can. It is a misconception that dogs can only see in black and white. According to AKC, examinations of the canine eye structure reveal that due to the nature of evolution and function, there are some basic differences in the design between dogs and humans. "Dogs developed their senses as nocturnal hunters," and due to this aspect of evolution, dogs eyes' are therefore adapted to see well in the dark and catch movement, which creates a larger lens and corneal surface and reflective membrane in dogs. Low-light vision in the retina is also improved, and the retina is the main focus of this color perception idea. Cones in the retina work and control color perception, and there are more rods than cones in a dogs eye. Because of this the wavelength color spectrum of dogs is differently perceived which causes them to see and miss certain colors.

To add on, according to PSU, dogs see minimal in color but do in fact see in color. In easier words, dogs see as a colorblind human would. The concept of the structure of the retina was also emphasized in this article.

<!--EndFragment-->

Comments

What is AKC? You mention it as your source but it is not clear what that is.

---

The AKC stands for the American Kennel Club. As stated on their about page, "For more than 130 years, the American Kennel Club has been the country’s leading authority on all things dogs." They are probably most well-known for their detailed information pages on dog breeds, but they have loads of information on health, responsible ownership, etc. Thus, a reliable source for the question of dogs' eyesight.

Answer 8

According to Adelaide Vet, a vet clinic in Australia, it's a myth that cats and dogs can only see black and white. Scientists have proven that the "perception of color is determined by the presence of cells in the eye called cone photoreceptors." Cats and dogs have two kinds of these cones that can see blue and green light. 

Because of this, cats and dogs are color-blind, but only to some color, not all. Humans have all three cones to see blue, green, and red light, but since cats and dogs only have two, they cannot see red light. Their eyes have a muted perception of red so they are colour-blind to that color. "For example, behavioural tests in dogs suggest that they can distinguish  red from blue, but often confuse red and green. Similarly, they often perceive green as grey.

https://adelaidevet.com.au/pet-library/can-animals-see-colour

Comments

Your explanation is clear and precise. The website that you found is amazing for people to learn more about pets and how to take care of them. The website is reliable, and you provided lots of explanations to the question, which helps reader to understand why the answer is false. Nice Work.

---

That's a solid post! You mention a clear source, the common misconception, and current evidence. I appreciate that you provide a clear explanation and a quote from your source. One thing exclusive to your post is the explanation of how dog's eyes view colors differently from humans. For example, you mentioned that dogs seen green as gray. This really helps the reader understand from a dog's point of view. I do think that adding another source would strengthen your claim. I also recommend restating the claim to clarify. Overall, this fact-check is a well-developed.

---

your response to the claim is very resourceful and helpful. we both agree that it is a myth that dogs can only see black and white. I'd also like to add that while dogs cannot see red, they also cannot see green.

Answer 9

It has been proven to be a myth that dogs can only see black and white.

According to "American Kennel Club"  dogs develop their senses as nocturnal hunters, tracking and catching their food at night. Their eyes are adapted to see well in the dark and catch movement.

Comments

Can you provide a hyperlink to your source?

Answer 10

This is false. Dogs can actually see color, just not as good as humans. Dogs have poor vision and can only see blue and yellow. According to American Kennel Club, “Dogs have more rods than cones in their retina, whereas people have more cones, and this apparently makes the difference in color perception.”

https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/health/can-dogs-see-color/

Comments

This a great response. You used a reputable website to find out that dogs can actually see color. You also quoted American Kennel Club which further strengthened your claim that this statement was false.

---

I appreciate how your factcheck is precise and detailed. The source you provided offers a solid explanation of dogs vision, and you did a good job of explaining the evidence the article offers. The website is reputable and the article was written recently. You also quoted the article in your claim, making it stronger.

---

Your fact-check is clear and concise, and your claim and summary align well with the source you provided. To make it even stronger, you could briefly explain what the American Kennel Club is and why it is considered a reputable source. Adding this context will help your audience understand why the information is trustworthy.

Additionally, you could deepen your explanation of your findings. While the source provides accurate information, it would strengthen your argument to clarify that the claim being addressed is incorrect—but this does not mean that dogs see colors exactly as humans do. You could also briefly explain the roles of cones and rods in vision, showing how they affect color perception and light sensitivity in both humans and dogs. This added detail will make your fact-check more thorough and informative.