Do Electric vehicles operate better in cold temperatures than gas-powered cars?

Question

It depends on what type of operation you are looking at. For example with range, cold temperatures can reduce the efficiency of the battery in electric vehicles leading to a decrease on range. With gas-powered car, the cold temperatures can affect fuel economy and the impact is generally less than electric.

Answer 1

I think this claim is a bit misleading. I found an interview with the AAA spokesperson on Fox Weather. Sinclair from AAA, said, "The cold affects the chemical reaction in the lithium-ion battery that powers an electric car, the same as it affects a lead-acid battery that starts the engine in a gasoline-powered car." In all, it seems both cars are affected by the cold.

https://www.foxweather.com/lifestyle/are-electric-cars-reliable-in-the-winter

Comments

This claim is surely misleading as it doesn't really speak to how many factors there are in driving too. A lot of companies have electric cars now with different battery spans, and a lot of cars have different miles per gallon, it isn't really fair to say one thing or the other. I think this a nice simple fact check that involves too many factors to develop a well said claim regarding these efficiencies.

---

You did a good job analyzing the claim through the use of this article and what it had to say. In the future, maybe look through a couple sources to see why this claim might have been exaggerated or if there is a sound basis for the claim (what part of that basis has been exaggerated).

---

The claim seems misleading because it oversimplifies the efficiency of cars by not considering various factors. Many companies produce electric cars with different battery spans, and traditional cars vary in miles per gallon. It's not fair to make a blanket statement without considering these diverse factors. Fact-checking this claim is challenging due to the complexity of the topic. Next time, consider exploring multiple sources to understand why a claim may have been exaggerated or if there's a valid basis for it. Investigate which aspects of the claim's foundation might have been overstated.

---

Absolutely, I agree with your assessment. The claim appears to be misleading because it oversimplifies the complexities of evaluating car efficiency. In the automotive landscape, many factors come into play, such as the introduction of electric cars by various companies, Additionally, traditional cars vary in miles per gallon. To make a fair judgment, it's crucial to consider this diversity rather than making a blanket statement. Fact-checking such a claim becomes challenging due to the multitude of factors involved in accurately assessing the efficiencies of different vehicles

---

After using the information and source you shared I agree with the fact that this headline is misleading and an exaggeration. You did a good addressing the claim at hand and proving it wrong discrediting that source. I would probably recommend adding some more background information about why the original source thought this, as well as maybe another source that also says its misleading and false.

Answer 2

According to Consumer Reports, cold temperatures negatively affect the batteries in electric vehicles. Cold temperatures can slow down the chemical reaction that occurs within the battery, and even more significantly when parked. During their testing, temperatures below 40 degrees Fahrenheit sap about 25% of driving range from electric vehicles. 

On the other hand, gas powered vehicles also lose driving range capabilities in cold weather. Based on findings from Energy Capital HTX, combustion engines fuel economy drops by 15-24% in temperatures below 20 degrees Fahrenheit. While they might be affected in different ways, both electric and gas powered cars lose driving range in cold temperatures. However, excluding factors such as vehicle age and driving terrain, electric cars appear to be affected more than gas cars in cold weather.

https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/hybrids-evs/how-much-do-cold-temperatures-affect-an-evs-driving-range-a5751769461/ 

https://energycapitalhtx.com/cold-weather-electric-vehicle-guest-column 

Comments

I really enjoyed reading your fact-check! I really appreciated that you used multiple sources to back up your findings. It is obvious that this is an oversimplification of how electric vehicles work under cold temperatures. Providing information on how gas-powered vehicles are also affected by cold temperatures is very helpful and helps show the full picture. It is clear this statement is exaggerated and misleading.