Dark Chocolate Can be beneficial for people with Diabetes

Question

Dark chocolate, especially varieties with at least 70% cocoa, can offer health benefits for people with diabetes when consumed in moderation. Flavonoids in dark chocolate have been shown to improve insulin sensitivity and help regulate blood sugar levels. It may also support cardiovascular health by improving blood flow and reducing blood pressure . However, due to its calorie density, excessive consumption can lead to weight gain, which may negatively affect glucose control. Choosing dark chocolate with minimal added sugar maximizes its potential benefits while minimizing drawbacks 

Answer 1

Yes, dark chocolate can offer potential benefits for individuals with Diabetes when consumed in moderation. Many research has been done on dark chocolate. Within dark chocolate there is about 70% of cocoa, which acts like as an antioxidant that helps insulin sensitivity and can reduce inflammation. These compounds can help regulate blood sugar levels and support overall heart health. There was a study done by Harvard Health and they found that individuals who consumed at least five ounces of dark chocolate weekly had a 21% lower rick of developing diabetes. Overall Its important to consume dark chocolate in moderations because there still is sugar, but not as much as your normal go to milk chocolate.

https://www.health.harvard.edu/diseases-and-conditions/can-dark-chocolate-help-you-avoid-diabetes?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Comments

I agree with your claim and I thought that your response was very well said and used a strong and effective source. I also found great points in the Harvard article and I think that you used a great outside source to support your claim.

---

Your argument is very well worded and convincing. It is also sound, with valid, supportive sources to back up your claims. The claim you are making is true and supported by many valid sources with supportive evidence to help make the claim more accurate.

---

I like how you started with how you agreed with the main claim, then led into more facts. Starting with the percentages and the number facts. Great job on finding a good source to back up your own claim and facts.

---

This response is thorough and includes the source, which also backs up the point you are making and is relevant to the research you've done. It was a good idea to use an entirely new source from the one provided in the original claim.

---

This is a great argument for the benefits of dark chocolate. One thing that might help would be to distinguish between the acts of preventing diabetes and managing diabetes if you already have it, or noting that not all "dark chocolate" products are created equal, some having much more sugar than others.

Answer 2

While this seems to be true for those with type 2 diabetes, it does not work the same for those with type 1. It is important to distinguish between types when making claims. This happens a lot with news articles.

https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/eating-dark-chocolate-linked-with-reduced-risk-of-type-2-diabetes/

Comments

Thank you for distinguishing that there is not link to dark chocolate and helping those with type 1 diabetes. Your source is very credible and up to date.

---

Even though this comment does give an article to back up your answer, you are still missing information. I'd say to put some words from the article in quotation marks. If you're able to find more articles that back up your answers as well, that would help with your comment. Other than that, I'd say that you did answer it well and did include a source to back yourself up.

---

Yes, totally agree with you about how diabetes 1 is different from diabetes 2 and how you have to take care of yourself.

---

I thought that this point was very interesting and important to voice, for there are differences between the two and I hadn't thought to look into how it effects or benefits the different types of diabetes. I thought that you used a strong and credible source and agree with you claim.

---

This is a great thing to point out, and after going back and reviewing the article, I think they could have made it clearer. It doesn't specifically state type 2 diabetes until about halfway through.

---

Great job at specifically pointing at the facts. I like how you make it clear that it only works with type 2 and not type 1 unlike the original claim did. Your source is also great and up to date with facts and also talks about more what you can do to help those cravings.

Answer 3

This claim is true. I looked at the article and traced the original source back to a National Library of Medicine study that found dark chocolate to be effective in preventing type 2 diabetes. The study found a 21% lower risk of T2D compared to people that rarely ate dark chocolate. This study shows clear scientific evidence that there is a link between eating dark chocolate and preventing type 2 diabetes. Eating milk chocolate was found to lead to weight gain. There was no substantial evidence of weight gain from eating (less than or equal to) 5 servings a week of dark chocolate. 

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39631943/

Comments

Your answer is succinct and well-sourced. It's made much more reliable by you finding the original source/study and being thorough. It's also very important that you specified the claim applies to type 2 diabetes only, and that dark chocolate is a preventative measure rather than helpful for people who already have T2D.

---

I like that your comment traces the original source and then you went through and made sure that the claim actually had followed what the article also claimed. While this is a good factcheck of their original source I would've loved to see if you could find another source that also supported your guys' claims.

---

I also read the same article from NIH and it is really proving information from a very reliable source. My question is did you find any other information that proves this claim to be true though? Because I see many people using the same two sources which is good, but is there any other information out there that could help even more from a source that is not from the original article? I believe it would make this claim even stronger if we found a variety of studies.

Answer 4

This article is from Abbott, a healthcare company that claims dark chocolate may benefit those with diabetes. This main argument, "Dark chocolate has the potential to help control your blood sugar — and could reduce your risk of diabetes if you don’t have it" comes from a cited report from endocrine-abstracts.org. Although not a large publication, the specific report was written by Grace Farhat, a registered nutritionist, and dietitian who graduated with a Ph.D. from Manchester Metropolitan University (Link). This indicates a likely reputable source, with research done in a scholarly manner. 

Regarding other studies on this topic, a study at Harvard also discovered a "clear split between dark and milk chocolate’s impact on diabetes risk and long-term weight management" (Link). This firmly backs up the original article's claim. Of course with all foods, there must be a consideration for consuming in moderation. Despite that, the original statement claims it "may be beneficial" which is true through these sources.

Comments

That is a very strong point with the argument. What I would want to see more of is some analysis of the kind of studies that are cited like was the study observational or experimental? Was it done on large groups or small groups? That would impact just how solid the evidence really is. Also, since Abbott is a health firm with a stake in nutrition products, a little extra skepticism about potential bias in how they present conclusions would strengthen your fact-check. Overall, though, this is a good, thought out and well-documented analysis!

Answer 5

Agreed, Dark chocolate has many health benefits that can help diabetics such as flavanoids and lower amounts of sugar. Lower amounts of sugar mean lower insulin spikes which is great for diabetics. Although maybe not "beneficial" definitely helpful

Comments

I agree with you as well about the lower amount of sugar the dark chocolate has in every article I have looked up, as said, almost the exact same thing.

---

What are flavanoids and how do they help? I agree with your statement but it might be a little stronger if you cited a source that can back your claim.

Answer 6

This claim seems to be partly true. The source seems to be reliable as Abbott is a well-known healthcare company. They also referenced scientific studies, including research published by Endocrine Abstracts and BMJ.  I agree that dark chocolate can be beneficial for people with diabetes as long as it is consumed in moderation and part of a balanced diet. Eating dark chocolate with at least 70% cocoa is preferable as it contains fewer added sugars and more beneficial compounds. However, dark chocolate is not a guaranteed way to manage diabetes. In a source I found from the National Institute of Health, it suggests that cocoa may be useful in slowing the progression of people with diabetes.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5699188/

Answer 7

Dark chocolate doesn't affect people with diabetes if it is at least 70% cocoa, especially with people with type 2 diabetes. There are other sweet snacks without worrying about spiking your sugar high. 

Link:https://www.everydayhealth.com/type-2-diabetes/diet/why-dark-chocolate-one-best-desserts-diabetics/

Comments

This claim can be true actually, and is not subjected to an opinion. There is good evidence from the NIH article supporting the claim scientifically, you should read it: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5699188/. You also seemed to list only one quote from the article and not explain your reasoning any more. I would encourage you to go into more detail.

Answer 8

This claim is true in regards to specific things in the chocolate that can benefit people that have diabetes. According to the article," Dark Chocolate and Diabetes; Heres the Breakdown of Benefits" by Abbott, "Dark chocolate contains polyphenols, which are naturally occurring compounds that have antioxidant properties...Polyphenols in dark chocolate may improve insulin sensitivity, or how well insulin works in the body. This, in turn, may help control blood sugar. Such improved insulin sensitivity may delay, or even prevent, the onset of diabetes." The article speaks on the benefits that specific aspects of dark chocolate can have certain aspects of having diabetes, for example an ingredient/property in dark chocolate may help control blood sugar and improve insulin sensitivity. Another article from Harvard Health and the article " Can Dark Chocolate Help You Avoid Diabetes?" speaks on the effects that eating dark chocolate in moderation can have on diabetes. The quotation "Scientists evaluated the self-reported dietary and health information of about 112,000 healthy middle-aged people who were followed for more than 30 years. Compared with people who rarely or never ate chocolate, those who had at least five ounces of dark chocolate each week had a 21% lower risk of developing diabetes," highlights the findings of a study that showed that least 5 ounces of dark chocolate a week created a lower risk of getting diabetes in comparison to those who only ate milk chocolate. The statements from the Abbott and Harvard article both share that Dark chocolate in moderation may benefit diabetes in regards to specific things, such as controlling blood sugar and insulin sensitivity. 

https://www.abbott.com/corpnewsroom/diabetes-care/dark-chocolate-and-diabetes.html

https://www.health.harvard.edu/diseases-and-conditions/can-dark-chocolate-help-you-avoid-diabetes?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Answer 9

Dark chocolate can help manage type 2 diabetes. The article specifically states that "polyphenol-rich dark chocolate" can help control blood sugar and insulin sensitivity. By doing a quick Google search, it's clear that this is a topic that has been extensively researched, which also makes it easy to verify or prove false. The article does a good job of explaining the specific health effects and products that are beneficial, and all of these claims are backed by the reliable sources that are cited.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39631943/

https://www.endocrine-abstracts.org/ea/0034/ea0034p206.htm

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4460349/

Answer 10

This claim is accurate and true. Dark chocolate is still sweet and should be consumed in moderation, like you said. Although it is good for you, it is important to monitor blood sugar levels when eating sweets. Dark chocolate does contain flavonoids, which are beneficial for the regulation of insulin. It is also very important to examine a package closely when choosing dark chocolate. The higher the percentage of cocoa, the better. Some contain 30 percent dark chocolate, and the rest is milk chocolate, according to Why Dark Chocolate Is One of the Best Desserts for Diabetics. Although dark chocolate can be a good treat, it is important to consume it in moderation, or it defeats the purpose of being a healthy alternative.