This appears to be satirical.
The source of this claim originates from the Dunning-Kruger Times, a satirical website named after the Dunning-Kruger Effect. On the website's About Us page, the organization claims to be part of a "network of parody, satire, and tomfoolery" and a subsidiary of America's Last Line of Defense. The about us page also states, importantly, that "everything on this website is fiction." The "writer" for this article is named Flagg Eagleton, a cartoonish stereotype of an American in both name and biography. The website Lead Stories has also checked this claim and found it to be false, originating in satire.
The Dunning-Kruger Times claims to be working against conservatives by exposing them to their own fallacies and seems to have a strong left-leaning bias as a result. This article, though, has three comments from people who seem to believe the events depicted and who seem to agree with this fake decision to release Kelce. I have found no other sources reporting on this claim, which means that its misleading effect may be limited to a smaller audience. Ideally, this website hopes to inform people of their own biases by deceiving them only for later, more reputable news to prove Dunning-Kruger false. While the information is intentionally false, it is created and distributed with intentions of being interpreted as satire, criticism, and entertainment.